NHL should consider relocation or contraction before expansion
Artist's concept of new Markham arena complex.
Jeff Hale, MSN Sports
It didn’t take long for the NHL to squash the expansion talk that emerged last week.
In the wake of council in Markham, Ont., approving the funds to build a $235-million NHL-sized arena last week -- without the guarantee of an NHL team -- Paul Kelly, the former executive director of the NHL Players’ Association from 2007 to 2009, said while he held that job the NHL had a plan to add two more teams and that they would land in Toronto and Quebec City. That would make for a 32-team league, a ridiculous notion in a shrinking economy.
NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly quickly raced up that hill to declare the league has no expansion plans “at this point” and described the previous talks as conceptual only.
The NHL has made this grab for cash before, most recently adding Minnesota and Columbus as expansion teams in 2000 for a fee of $80 million (US) each. The fees for the next round of expansion are projected to be in the hundreds of millions, a tidy windfall indeed. Expect that compensation to be paid with nary a blink if the team is destined for a Canadian location.
The league would prefer to do this on its own timetable, though. That means scotching expansion talk right now and possibly using prospective arenas in Markham, Quebec City and Seattle as leverage for a struggling team, like, say, the Phoenix Coyotes. The league seems hellbent on fighting for the Coyotes until the last cactus has wilted but eventually the battle will become futile even for the NHL. The league will need ready destinations if it has to move the Coyotes or any other team hearing crickets at the ticket office.
Relocation or even contraction should be the NHL’s preferred options, especially since Forbes magazine reported 13 teams lost money last season. But rare is the pro sports league that gives up on an existing market. That is a mistake laid bare, whereas expansion, however misguided, comes with the patina of financial health. And all that cash.
fox sports exclusives
recently recommended stories
What was the biggest sports story of 2013?
Thanks for being one of the first people to vote. Results will be available soon. Check for results
- NHL lockout ends — Chicago Blackhawks win Stanley Cup
- Boston Marathon bombing followed by Boston Strong support and the Boston Red Sox winning the World Series at home
- Toronto Maple Leafs' Game 7 collapse against the Boston Bruins
- Saskatchewan Roughriders host and win the 101st Grey Cup
- LeBron James leads the Miami Heat to a second consecutive NBA Championship
- Lights out at Super Bowl XLVII
- Historic winning streaks of the Chicago Blackhawks and Miami Heat
- MLB's steroid investigation and player suspensions
- Aaron Hernandez charged with murder
- Oscar Pistorius charged with murder
- Lance Armstrong admits to doping
- The Manti Te'o hoax